Let’s take this incident that happened in front of the Lincoln Memorial on Friday, during the March for Life Event. With so many people gathered already for political activism, the event attracted fringe elements of society attempting to publicize their agenda. One such group was the Black Hebrew Israelites.
The Black Hebrew Israelites stood at the base of the steps, spewing racist, offensive hate. Their goal was to spark confrontation, at which they succeeded several times.
Eventually, the Black Hebrew Israelites began an offensive roll of insults against the Catholic Church. At this point, the group begins to attract the attention of male students from Covington Catholic High School, many of whom happen to be wearing red MAGA hats.
The Black Hebrew Israelites then spews hate and insults directly at the students. The initial reaction was for the students to leave. Over the next twenty to twenty-five minutes, as the group continues to spew hatred, little by little, the student gather on the steps in back of and to the right of the group, keeping a distance of several yards. (Some have reported that the students were waiting for buses.)
As the speakers begin to notice the growth in students in their audience, they target the students directly for an offensive tirade. The students respond by drowning out the speakers with sports cheers and chants. As the adrenaline flows, one attention-grabbing student runs to the front of his friends, and strips his shirt off as his friends scream in support. The boy then leads the groups in what appears to be a tribal-like cheer (the Haka?) that many sports teams have adopted as a show of intimidation. The crowd howls its approval.
The crowd continues with a more popular and recognizable sports chant. It was at this point that Daniel Phillips, an activist for indigenous people’s rights, decided to intervene. Beating a rhythmic pattern on a hand-held drum, engaging in a chant, Phillips marched directly toward and then into the crowd of students. Phillips later stated he approached the students, and not the Black Hebrew Israelites, because the group of students was much larger and mostly white.
As Phillips approached the students, they gave no ground. Phillips walked straight towards one student, who smirked, but who did not move as Phillips banged the drum in his face. The rest of the students reacted by chanting as well, and then clapping in time with the drum.
The chant devolved into a chant made famous by the Florida State Seminoles, and popular for other teams with Native American mascots: The Chop. This includes the Atlanta Braves, where Deion Sanders brought the chant after attending FSU.
Certainly, this is not Christian behavior, and deserves a talk from Christian Youth leaders on how to respond to such aggressive behavior by others in a way that is consistent with Christian values and beliefs. But the worst thing the students did was to use sports chants popular with teams that have Native American mascots. The students were not the aggressors.
Daniel Phillips must shoulder some blame for being unduly aggressive. He has himself admitted that he chose to talk toward and into the group of students because they were a larger group and mostly white. Absent from his analysis was the provocations consistently made by the Black Hebrew Israelites. The group had been spewing hatred aimed at numerous ethnicities, and religious groups. Yet, in the reporting, almost any recognition of this offense behavior, let alone condemnation of the group, is absent. For the mainstream press, it is enough that there was a confrontation and white kids involved wearing MAGA hats. Obviously, the Trump supporters must be to blame.
By: William J. Kovatch, Jr.
Note: I used to consider myself a Republican until Trump won the nomination in 2016. I am no supporter of Trump, or of the Republican Party, which appears to be full of nothing but sycophants. Nonetheless, I refuse to jump on a popular band wagon when a full analysis of the facts points in a different direction. The true problem with modern American journalism, I believe, is laziness. Just report the same line you were programmed to believe over and over. I pray greater objectivity comes back to American press soon.
No comments:
Post a Comment