Header Photo

Header Photo
Showing posts with label white house. Show all posts
Showing posts with label white house. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 9, 2019

Refusing to Cooperate with the Impeachment Inquiry, Trump Shows His Disdain for the House of Representatives

Throwing down a gauntlet in front of House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, President Donald Trump announced that he will no longer permit his Administration to cooperate with the House of Representative's impeachment inquiry.  In furtherance of Trump's defiance of the House, U.S. Ambassador to the European Union, Gordon Sondland, who played a key role in Trump's pressuring of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky to investigate political rival Joe Biden, failed to testify at a House hearing.  Sondland skipped the hearing at the instruction of Trump's State Department.  Counsel to the President, Pat Cippollone confirmed the decision to impede the House investigation through a letter to Democratic House leaders, written on the President's behalf on White House stationary.

While this move to escalate the tension between the Democratically-controlled House and the Trump Administration will play well with Trump's supporters, who revel in the idea of a no-holds-bar fight with ideologically opposed parties, Trump's outward contempt for the House risks a more aggressive push for his impeachment.

Although Trump holds the Democratic leaders in Congress in disdain, congress is obliged to oversee the actions of the Executive Branch.  This is all part of the checks and balances of the U.S. Constitution, which seeks to ensure that no one branch of government dominates over the other two.  It is a power meant to guard against tyranny and authoritarianism. 

Given the gravity of the current situation, the President must be willing to provide information to Congress, and make members of his Administration available for testimony.

In this regard, some communications with the President may be privileged due to national security or the public interest. But a wholesale refusal to cooperate with congressionally issued subpoenas can hardly be justified, especially after the President himself released a memorandum of a telephone call between Trump and Zelensky where Trump clearly requested the Ukrainian President's help in gathering dirt against Trump's political rival, Joe Biden.  As the head of the Federal Elections Commission confirmed in June of this year, the act of soliciting something of value (in this case research on an opponent) in connection with a federal election is in and of itself a violation of law.  If the President pressured Ukraine by withholding congressionally approved military aid, his behavior becomes all the more egregious.

In the middle of this situation stands the U.S. Ambassador to the E.U.  Trump dismissed the U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine, Marie Yovanovich, because she stood in the way of Trump's efforts to have Ukraine investigate Joe Biden and his son, Hunter.  Despite the fact that Ukraine is not a member of the European Union, Sondland took over the role of coordinating the U.S. Government's policy with respect to the Ukraine.  Recently, text messages involving Sondland surfaced, strongly suggesting that Trump was using the military aid to pressure Ukraine.  Sondland's testimony, therefore, is important to determine the extent of the President's malfeasance.

Trump's refusal to permit Sondland, or any other member of the Administration, to cooperate with the House inquiry appears as a powerful indication that Trump has something to hide.  Moreover, given that Robert Mueller and his team of investigators have already documented Trump's tendency to obstruct official investigations, the President is courting yet another reason for his impeachment; that is obstruction of Congress.

In this regard, the President's Counsel charges that the impeachment inquiry violates the President's due process rights, and fails to follow accepted procedures from prior impeachment inquiries.  Cipollone's criticism of the House is misguided as he fails to recognize the purpose behind the separate steps of the impeachment and removal process, as well as the breadth of authority the Constitution grants the House over impeachment proceedings.

The Constitution is not concerned with the personal rights and interests of the person who happens to occupy the Office of President.  Nor should it be.  The Constitution is concerned with the well-being of the Republic.  In this regard, the President acts as a fiduciary, a person who is required to suppress his or her own personal interests, in favor of making decisions that are in the best interests of the people of the United States.

This is why impeachment is not a criminal proceeding, nor should it be treated as one.  Impeachment is about the integrity of the U.S. Government.  At one point in his political career, the President's staunchest defender in the Senate agreed with this principle.  Senator Lindsey Graham, serving as a Representative in the House of Representative in 1999, said of impeachment:
  • You don’t even have to be convicted of a crime to lose your job in this constitutional republic if this body[, the House of Representatives,] determines that your conduct as a public official is clearly out of bounds in your role. . . .  Impeachment is not about punishment. Impeachment is about cleansing the office. Impeachment is about restoring honor and integrity to the office.
At the time, Graham was arguing in favor of the impeachment of President Bill Clinton, who lied while under oath about a sexual relationship he had with a White House intern.  Graham not only pressed for Clinton's impeachment in the House, but also served as a House Manager during Clinton's trial in the Senate.  As Manager, Graham was tasked with presenting the reasons why the House concluded Clinton should be removed from office.
 
Yet, consistent with the President's narcissism, Trump's public defense against impeachment has, many times, focused on Trump's personal interests, and not the best interests of the United States.  Thus, Trump makes claims concerning personal legal rights, like the argument that his lawyers should be permitted to cross-examine witnesses and call witnesses of their own.
 
But impeachment is not a criminal proceeding.  It is a political one.  Article I of the Constitution grants the House of Representatives "the sole Power of Impeachment."  There are no other provisions in the Constitution which define the role of the House in impeachment, or the procedures that the House must follow.  It is therefore up to the House itself to define its own rules and proceed accordingly.
 
The Constitution is very specific on effects of an impeachment.  It stands as but the first step in a process to determine whether to remove a person from civil office.  Pursuant to Article II, once the House has impeached the President, the Senate then holds a trial, with the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court presiding.  The Senate can only convict with a two-thirds majority.  Article II, Section 3, Clause 7 of the Constitution limits the effect of impeachment:
  • Judgment in cases of impeachment shall not extend further than to removal from Office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any Office of honor, Trust or Profit under the United States; but the Party convicted shall nevertheless be liable and subject to Indictment, Trial, Judgment and Punishment, according to law.
The Constitution may use words such as "trial" and "conviction" which are reminiscent of criminal law.  But it is clear that impeachment is not meant to be punishment.  The Constitution reserves the decision on whether a person removed from office will be subject to any criminal proceeding and criminal punishment to the appropriate law enforcement authorities.
 
Nonetheless, analogies can be made between criminal process and the impeachment and removal of a president.  In this regard, impeachment can be seen as similar to a grand jury proceeding, through which a prosecutor can seek an indictment.  This is the decision to charge a person with a crime and hold a trial.  But even in criminal law, at that first stage of a criminal prosecution, not all of the personal rights enumerated in the Constitution apply.  A person subject to a grand jury proceeding is not entitled to the right of legal counsel or the right to cross-examine witnesses.  Moreover, the Government in a grand jury proceeding is not required to present evidence that favors the accused.
 
To support the argument that the House is proceeding unfairly, the White House relies on certain procedures followed in prior impeachment processes.  But again, this fails to recognize that the House has the "sole Power of Impeachment."  The House is not bound to follow any procedures established in prior impeachment proceedings.  In addition, because impeachment is a political act, not a criminal law proceeding, it is not subject to judicial review.  Under the political questions doctrine, the courts will not hear a case when the Constitution textually commits the issue to one of the political branches of government, that is Congress or the Executive.  Because the text of the Constitution unequivocally gives the power over impeachment to the House, the courts will not review the exercise of that power.  What process the House will follow that leads up to a vote on articles of impeachment is simply up to the discretion of the House and its leaders.

Another argument that Trump uses to support his decision to thwart the impeachment inquiry is that the Democrats in the House are attempting to overturn the 2016 presidential election.  He likens impeachment to a coup.  But again, impeachment and removal from office are powers granted the House and Senate in order to protect against the abuse of office by the President.  It is an entirely appropriate procedure to invoke when a president uses his authority to conduct foreign policy in manner that benefits himself privately.  The Constitution protects against the abuse of the impeachment and removal power by dividing authority between the House and the Senate.  Thus, impeachment itself does not remove a president from office.  Rather, he must be convicted after a trial in the Senate.  Moreover, in order to convict, the Constitution requires a super-majority of two-thirds before a president can be removed from office.  Safeguards therefore exist to ensure that the process is a deliberative one, and not merely a negation of an election.

Indeed, even if the President is impeached, his Vice President will assume the Office of President.  The President and Vice President run together on the same ticket.  Presumably, with both the President and Vice President coming from the same political party. the Vice President will agree with the major policy objectives of the President.  An impeachment, therefore, does not overturn an election.  It simply is one step in removing a person who has shown an unfitness to hold the Office, leaving the President's political party in charge of Executive Branch.

Sadly, Trump's presidency has never been about what is best for the American people.  It has always been about Trump's self-aggrandizement.  He has sought outright flattery from his Cabinet members.  He attempts to enforce personal loyalty, and not loyalty to the Constitution and the rule of law.  He has publicly stated that he sees nothing wrong with accepting help with finding disparaging information on a political opponent from a foreign source.  He has viewed an investigation about national security, namely the investigation of Russian interference in the 2016 election, as an investigation of himself instead of as the counter-intelligence investigation it was.  When he sees an investigation as potential detrimental to his personal interests, he engages in witness tampering and otherwise attempts to obstruct that investigation.  His current refusal is simply a continuation of that behavior.  His continued willingness to thwart the law and investigations into his conduct  should be considered as a violation of the trust he holds from the American people, and featured prominently in the House's deliberations on whether to impeach him.

By: William J. Kovatch, Jr.
 

Thursday, August 3, 2017

The Beginning of the End of the Trump Presidency?

I don't think it will be long now.

Shortly after the election, I had lunch with a friend who was amazed that I predicted a Donald Trump victory even when he was far behind in the polls. I made another prediction that day, telling her that I did not believe Trump would last his entire term.

My reasoning?  He didn't do this for any grand policy reasons or love of country. He ran for love of Trump. Trump is a skillful self-promoter and learned very well how to get ratings in a reality tv world. He used that to manipulate his popular name and give the public a very entertaining (albeit disturbingly so) campaign. But he doesn't have the skills to govern.

If you look at his business career, how did he function?  It wasn't through any powerful negotiating skills, or business acumen. It was simply by throwing his money around. Just ask the many contractors who worked on Trump projects but never got paid their contracted rates. Presumably, they were attracted to work on his real estate developments by his name and the promise of full payment. But when push came to shove, and full payment was not forthcoming, Trump's response was to say "sue me."  Since the little guy knew Trump had the means to buy fancy lawyers and tie up any lawsuit in protracted litigation, the little guy would give in and take what crumbs Trump had to offer. Money won.

But that was not going to be the reality of the world Trump was facing once he got in the White House. The President may be the focus point of government, mostly because it's easier for the media to follow one person. But the government consists of another 535 large egos residing just down the road on Pennsylvania Avenue as well as thousands of independently minded people in the judiciary. These are people who have their own sources of power, and are not solely dependent on Trump for their position. I explained to my friend that Trump was going to find that he couldn't always get what he wanted simply by throwing his name and money around. This was particularly true given how small the Republican majority in the Senate was, and how he had personally insulted many GOP Senators.

Trump enjoyed greater support in the House. But that was due mainly to GOP gerrymandering which had given disproportionately large power to the most radical wing of the Republican Party, all in the name of creating safe GOP districts. It is this wing of party that supported Trump largely due to their hate for Barrack Obama and Hillary Clinton, and because Trump was willing to entertain them with aggressive attacks on their Democratic opponents. But no one with any hint of intelligence had ever accused Trump of being a true conservative.

So conservatives in the House who did not like Trump would simply be biting their lips and biding their time until Trump was no longer useful to them. If Satan himself could get their agenda passed, well then so be it, so long as Satan had a high approval rating.

But, a number of things have happened since Inauguration Day. First, starting on day one, the press has refused to give the President the adoration he thinks he deserves, engaging in a constant battle with the Administration. And during much of this battle, the press has unearthed inaccuracy after inaccuracy from the White House.

Second, the President reportedly has become increasingly dissatisfied with his job, as he did not realize the full magnitude of what running a government would entail. It is as if Trump expected that once he became President, all he had to do was be the face of the government, and receive the adulation of the people. He falsely convinced himself of his own popularity, and has been surprised that running the White House was not as easy as putting on the show of running a fake executive board room on tv.

Third, in his dissatisfaction with the job, and his drive to be popular, he allegedly isolated himself into spending an inordinate amount of time watching tv news and talk shows, and then uncontrollably tweeting nasty things about those he thought were mean to him.

Fourth, he offered no vision or support for what was supposedly his agenda, other than cajoling other Republicans. As a result, his own party's long-running promise to repeal Obamacare crumbled. Trump was left unable to fathom how a GOP majority in both houses could fail to pass a bill, indeed any bill, on the subject. And as his agenda has failed, he has repeatedly and publicly attacked members of his own party in Congress. Indeed, whenever his agenda has faced road blocks from other people in power, his response has always been to attack other branches of government. This is the same thing he did to the judiciary as his travel ban faced defeat after defeat in the courts.

Fifth, more interested in protecting his name, Trump has engaged in behaviors that appear to many to be a cover-up, if not a campaign of obstruction of justice, regarding the investigation of Russia's possible involvement in the presidential election. His megalomaniacal drive to kill the investigation has led to the firing of an FBI Director, attacks on an Attorney General who had been his earliest and most loyal supporter, consideration of self-pardoning, a desire to fire the new investigator, and possibly creating legal jeopardy for his own son.

Sixth, his own staff in the White House has descended into chaos. Indeed, with all of the seismic changes in staffing, it has recently been reported that Reince Priebus and Steve Bannon, who were thought to be bitter rivals at the beginning of the Administration, had become close allies just before Priebus' firing in an effort for self-preservation against the Trump inner circle. It is chaos of the President's own making and apparent entertainment, as it has been reported that he fired Priebus for failing to lower himself to Anthony Scaramucci's level and fight back against the Mooch's shockingly base attacks.

It is a chaos that required a former Marine Corps General, who's major accomplishment in the Administration to date had been to threaten to separate mothers from their children as they sought to cross the southern border desperately seeking to flee the violence in Central America, to assume control of the White House staff and fire the colorful but abrasive Director of Communications after the Mooch had been on the job for only ten days.

And finally, polls have been published showing not only historically low approval ratings for Trump, but also that the House of Representatives could very well be in play in the mid-term elections.

It is this last development that could very well be the turning point. It appears that Trump may no longer be useful to congressional Republicans. Indeed, his brand name may even bet hurtful to their electoral aspirations. With the President showing that he cannot even be loyal to members of his own party, will they now be loyal to him?

Based on all of these developments, I would not be surprised if efforts are being made to gently push Trump into resignation. He is reportedly not happy being in the "dump" of the White House, and spends so much time outside of Washington anyway. As much as the GOP desperately want Chief of Staff Kelly to control the President, Trump will be who Trump is. He cannot be pushed to the shadows of his own presidency while the big boys do the actual governing. And so, with Republican pressure, I think the time is nearing where the Trump Presidency will end. If his poll numbers keep declining, the party will either find a face-saving way to have Trump resign, or they will find the backbone to remove him.

William J. Kovatch, Jr.